Two of the longest-running US independent holistic brands. Solid Gold dates to 1974 (one of the first 'holistic' US pet foods); Canidae founded 1996.
Average score: 71/100. 32 products. Country: US.
Average score: 64/100. 73 products. Country: US.
On overall score, Solid Gold wins by 6 points across the analyzed catalog (71 vs 64). Catalog breadth: Canidae (73 products) is broader than the smaller line (32).