Kit & Kaboodle® Original Adult Cat Dry Food - Poultry, Liver, Ocean Fish

by Kit 'N Kaboodle

Overall Score: 28/100

Ingredients

1. Ground Yellow Corn (carbohydrate)
2. Corn Protein Meal (other)
3. Soybean Meal (carbohydrate)
4. Meat And Bone Meal (protein)
5. Poultry By-Product Meal (protein)
6. Animal Fat Preserved With Mixed-Tocopherols (other)
7. Liver Flavor (other)
8. Calcium Carbonate (mineral)
9. Phosphoric Acid (other)
10. Salt (mineral)
11. Choline Chloride (vitamin)
12. Ocean Fish Meal (protein)
13. Taurine (additive)
14. MINERALS [Zinc Sulfate (other)
15. Ferrous Sulfate (mineral)
16. Manganese Sulfate (other)
17. Copper Sulfate (other)
18. Calcium Iodate (mineral)
19. Sodium Selenite] (other)
20. Potassium Chloride (mineral)
21. Salt (mineral)
22. VITAMINS [Vitamin E Supplement (other)
23. Niacin (Vitamin B-3) (other)
24. Vitamin A Supplement (vitamin)
25. Calcium Pantothenate (Vitamin B-5) (other)
26. Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B-1) (other)
27. Riboflavin Supplement (Vitamin B-2) (other)
28. Vitamin B-12 Supplement (other)
29. Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (Vitamin B-6) (other)
30. Folic Acid (Vitamin B-9) (other)
31. Vitamin D-3 Supplement (other)
32. Biotin (Vitamin B-7) (other)
33. Menadione Sodium Bisulfite Complex (Vitamin K)] (other)
34. DL-Methionine (other)
35. Red 40 (additive)
36. Yellow 5 (additive)
37. Blue 2 (additive)

Ingredient concerns

• Corn (medium concern): Corn is one of the most common allergens in dogs, though true corn allergies are relatively rare compared to protein allergies. Often used as an inexpensive filler to increase bulk. While it does provide digestible carbohydrates, its prominence in ingredient lists (especially as multiple corn-derived ingredients) can indicate a lower-quality formulation.
• Soy (medium concern): Soy is a common allergen in dogs and cats. It contains phytoestrogens that may affect hormonal balance, though the clinical significance in pets is not fully established. Often used as an inexpensive protein and carbohydrate filler. Most soy in pet food is genetically modified.
• Meat and Bone Meal (medium concern): Like meat meal, it does not specify the species source. The inclusion of bone increases the ash/mineral content and may lower overall protein digestibility. Quality varies widely between manufacturers. Generally considered a lower-quality protein source.
• Sodium Selenite (low concern): Sodium selenite is an inorganic form of selenium with a narrower safety margin than organic forms (such as selenium yeast). It has lower bioavailability and higher potential for toxicity at elevated levels compared to organic selenium sources. Some premium pet foods use selenium yeast instead as a safer alternative.
• Menadione Sodium Bisulfite Complex (high concern): Menadione (vitamin K3) is a synthetic form of vitamin K that has been banned for use in human dietary supplements in many countries due to toxicity concerns, including potential liver damage, allergic reactions, and cytotoxicity. It can cause oxidative damage to cell membranes. Natural forms of vitamin K (K1 from plants, K2 from bacterial fermentation) are considered safer alternatives. Despite these concerns, it remains widely used in pet food as an inexpensive vitamin K source.
• Red 40 (high concern): Provides no nutritional benefit whatsoever and is added solely for the visual appeal to human buyers, as dogs and cats have limited color vision. Multiple studies have raised concerns about behavioral effects in children, leading the EU to require warning labels on foods containing Red 40. Some animal studies have suggested potential genotoxicity, though results are debated. The FDA maintains it is safe at approved levels, but many veterinary nutritionists recommend avoiding artificial colors entirely.
• Yellow 5 (high concern): Like Red 40, Yellow 5 provides no nutritional value and is added only for appearance. It has been associated with hypersensitivity reactions and behavioral effects in children in multiple studies. Banned or restricted in several countries. The EU requires warning labels on products containing tartrazine. No legitimate reason for its inclusion in pet food.
• Blue 2 (high concern): Another artificial color with zero nutritional value. Some studies have found associations with brain tumors in male rats at high doses, though these findings are not universally accepted. Like other artificial colors, it exists in pet food solely for marketing purposes and offers no benefit to the animal.

Guaranteed analysis (dry-matter basis)

On a dry-matter basis (water removed for a fair wet-vs-dry comparison): protein 31.8%, fat 12.5%, fiber 3.4%, ash 7.5%, carbohydrate 44.8%. By calories: 29.7% from protein, 28.4% from fat, 41.9% from carbohydrate.

AAFCO compliance

This food meets the AAFCO adult cat nutrient minimums we can verify — protein 31.8% vs 26% minimum, fat 12.5% vs 9% minimum.

Dry food, with grains, for the adult life stage.

Similar products

• Instinct® Grain Free Kitten Food - Natural, Chicken — 100/100
• Nulo MedalSeries Signature Stews Cat & Kitten Food - Variety Pack, 12 ct, 33.6 oz — 100/100
• Nulo Shreds with Organ Meat Wet Cat & Kitten Food - Variety Pack, 12-Count, 33.6 oz — 100/100
• Nutro Perfect Portions Adult Wet Cat Food - Pate, Variety Pack, 24 Count — 100/100
• Simply Nourish Natural Kitten Wet Food - Pate, 3 oz — 100/100

As an Amazon Associate, KibbleWatcher earns from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. Our scoring is independent of any affiliate revenue.