Temptations Cat Food Review
Average score: 58/100 across 32 cat food products.
Top Temptations products
- Temptations™ Meaty Bites Soft & Savory Adult Cat Treat - 1.5 oz — 99/100
- Temptations™ Creamy Purée Lickable Adult Cat Treats - Salmon — 94/100
- Temptations™ Creamy Purée Lickable Adult Cat Treats - Chicken — 90/100
- Temptations™ Creamy Purée Lickable Adult Cat Treats - Puree, Tuna — 89/100
- Temptations™ Lickable Puree Kitten Cat Treat - 1.7 Oz — 88/100
All Temptations products (32)
- Temptations™ Birthday Adult Cat Treats - Lobster & Beef — 86/100
- Temptations™ Lickable Spoons Cat Treats - 1.4 oz — 80/100
- Temptations™ Mixups Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Catnip Fever — 75/100
- Temptations™ Bites In Gravy Adult Wet Cat Food - Variety Pack, Chicken and Seafood, 12 Ct, 42 — 69/100
- Temptations™ Mixups Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Backyard Cookout — 66/100
- Temptations Adult Complete Nutrition Dry Cat Food - Seafood Medley — 62/100
- Temptations Pate In Gravy Adult Wet Cat Food - 3.5oz — 60/100
- Temptations™ Adult Cat Treats - 6.3 Oz — 59/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats — 59/100
- Temptations Bites In Gravy Adult Wet Cat Food - 3.5oz — 58/100
- Temptations™ Classic Kitten Cat Treat - Dairy & Chicken — 54/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Tantalizing Turkey — 54/100
- Block Party BBQ — 50/100
- Creamy dairy flavor — 49/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Blissful Catnip — 48/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Savory Salmon — 48/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Tasty Chicken — 48/100
- Temptations™ Classics Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Shrimpy Shrimp — 48/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Tempting Tuna — 45/100
- Temptations™ Classic Kitten Cat Treat - Dairy & Salmon — 43/100
- Temptations™ Mixups Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Surfers' Delight — 42/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Crabby Crab — 32/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Creamy Dairy — 32/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Seafood Medley — 32/100
- Temptations™ Classics Adult Cat Treats - Soft & Crunchy, Rockin' Lobster — 32/100
- Temptations™ Classic Adult Cat Treats - Indoor Care, Soft & Crunchy, Chicken — 28/100
- Tasty Chicken Flavor — 19/100
Frequently asked questions
Is Temptations WSAVA-aligned?
Temptations is not on our WSAVA-aligned shortlist. That doesn't automatically mean the food is poor quality — many strong brands haven't pursued WSAVA recognition — but it means we lack independent confirmation of feeding-trial validation and on-staff veterinary nutritionist staffing.
Has Temptations ever been recalled?
No Temptations products match any FDA recall in our tracked feed. Two caveats worth stating plainly: our feed covers FDA recall notices from late 2025 onward, so a recall older than that would not appear here; and brand matching is deliberately conservative, so a recall naming a parent company or a co-manufacturer rather than Temptations itself may not be linked. For a definitive answer, check the FDA's own recall database.
How does Temptations score in our analysis?
Temptations averages 58/100 across 32 products in our catalog. Individual product scores combine ingredient quality, AAFCO compliance, and controversial-additive severity. See the methodology page for the full algorithm.
As an Amazon Associate, KibbleWatcher earns from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. Our scoring is independent of any affiliate revenue.