Simply Nourish Pet Food Review

Made by PetSmart house brand in US.

Average score: 82/100 across 164 pet food products.

PetSmart-exclusive private label. Product descriptions are explicitly tagged "Only at PetSmart."

Top Simply Nourish products

1. Simply Nourish® Original Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, Natural, Pate, With-Grain — 100/100
2. Simply Nourish® Original Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, Natural, Morsels in Broth, With-Grain — 99/100
3. Simply Nourish Cat - Adult, Wet Food, Source, Pate, 3 OZ — 98/100
4. Simply Nourish Natural Kitten Wet Food - Pate, 3 oz — 98/100
5. Simply Nourish Natural Kitten Wet Food - Pate, Split Cups, 2.65 oz — 98/100

All Simply Nourish products (164)

• Simply Nourish Cat - Adult, Wet Food, Pate, Tuna, 3 OZ — 98/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken, Beef & Pasta Stew, 10 oz — 98/100
• Simply Nourish Cat - Adult, Wet Food, Stews, Shredded, Chicken, Quail Egg, 2.8 OZ — 98/100
• Simply Nourish Source Natural Adult Cat Food - Hight Protein, Grain Free, Pate, 3 oz — 98/100
• Simply Nourish Adult Wet Cat Food - Shreds in Cream Sauce, 5.5 Oz — 97/100
• Simply Nourish Kitten Wet Food - Tender Morsels in Broth, 3 Oz — 97/100
• Simply Nourish Natural Wet Cat Food - Pate, 5.5 oz — 97/100
• Simply Nourish® Natural Solutions Hip & Joint All Life Stage Dog Meal Topper - 3 Oz., — 96/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, Natural, Shreds in Creamy Sauce, With-Grain — 96/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Kitten Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, Natural, Morsels in Broth, With-Grain — 96/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Adult Dry Dog Food - Lamb, Pork & Boar, Grain Free — 95/100
• Simply Nourish® Natural Solutions Digestion Adult Wet Cat Food - Natural, With Grain — 95/100
• Simply Nourish® Shreds in a Creamy Sauce Kitten Wet Cat Food - Natural, With Grain — 95/100
• Simply Nourish Source Adult - High Protein, Salmon & Grain — 95/100
• Simply Nourish Source Natural Adult Cat Food - Grain Free, Shreds, 2.8 oz — 95/100
• Simply Nourish Source Adult Wet Dog Food - Variety Pack, 6 ct — 95/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Indoor Cat Dry Food - Fish & Chicken, Natural, High-Protein, Grain Free — 94/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Wet Dog Food - Chicken & Turkey Stew, 10 oz — 94/100
• Simply Nourish Natural Adult Wet Cat Food - Grain Free, Pate, 3 oz — 94/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Puppy Wet Dog Food - 3 Oz., Stew — 94/100
• Simply Nourish Layers Natural Adult Wet Cat Food - Pate & Shreds, 3 oz — 93/100
• Simply Nourish Source Adult - High Protein, Chicken & Grains — 93/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken & Beef Stew, 10 oz — 93/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken & Beef Stew, 3 oz — 93/100
• Simply Nourish Adult Wet Cat Food - Tender Morsels in Broth, 3 Oz — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Shreds in a Creamy Sauce Adult Wet Cat Food - Natural, With Grain — 92/100
• Simply Nourish Source Chicken Adult — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Adult Dry Dog Food - Salmon, High-Protein, Grain Free — 92/100
• Simply Nourish Cat - Adult, Wet Food, Stew, Cup, 2.8 OZ — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Kitten Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, High-Protein, Pate, Grain Free — 92/100
• Simply Nourish Homestyle Meal Topper™ Adult Dog Meal Complement - 9 oz — 92/100
• Simply Nourish Natural Cat Food Topper - Broth with Shreds, 1.4 oz — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Shreds & Flaked, Chicken & Tuna Stew, 10 oz — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Shreds & Flaked, Chicken & Tuna Stew, 3 oz — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Cat Meal Topper - 3 Oz, Natural, High-Protein, Grain Free — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Dog Meal Topper - Shreds, 3 Oz. — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Indoor Adult Pate Wet Cat Food - Natural, Grain Free — 92/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Cat Wet Food - 2.8 Oz, High-Protein, Stew, Grain Free — 92/100
• Simply Nourish Puppy Wet Dog Food - Minced, Chicken & Vegetable in Broth, 10 oz — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Fresh Market Adult Frozen Dog Food - Beef & Barley — 91/100
• Simply Nourish Kitten Wet Food - Natural, Mousse, 3 Oz — 91/100
• Simply Nourish Senior Wet Dog Food - Minced, Chicken & Vegetable in Broth, 10 oz — 91/100
• Simply Nourish Wet Dog Food - Minced, Chicken & Vegetable in Broth, 10 oz — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Mousse Cat Meal Topper - Natural, 3 Oz — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Cat Dry Food - Chicken & Turkey, Natural, High-Protein, Grain Free — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Urinary Tract Health Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, Natural — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Urinary Tract Health Cat Wet Food - 3 Oz, Natural, With-Grain — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Wet Food - Shreds & Flaked, Stew, Grain Free, 2.8 Oz — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Weight Management Adult Dry Dog Food - Turkey & Brown Rice — 91/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Adult Dry Dog Food - Chicken, Pea & Potato — 90/100
• Simply Nourish Wet Dog Food - Minced, Beef & Vegetable in Broth, 10 oz — 90/100
• Simply Nourish Wet Dog Food - Minced, Duck & Vegetable in Broth, 10 oz — 90/100
• Simply Nourish Wet Dog Food - Minced, Lamb & Vegetable in Broth, 10 oz — 90/100
• Simply Nourish® Natural Solutions Gut Health All Life Stage Dog Meal Topper - 3 Oz., — 90/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Wet Dog Food - Duck & Venison Stew, 10 oz — 90/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Beef & Rice, 10 oz — 90/100
• Simply Nourish® Original All Life Stage Dog Meal Topper - 3 Oz., — 90/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Wet Dog Food - Variety Pack, 6 ct — 90/100
• Simply Nourish Cat - Kitten, Wet Food, Stew, Grain Free, Chicken, Salmon, 2.8 OZ — 90/100
• Simply Nourish® Kitten Cat Wet Food - Variety Pack, 12 CT, 36 OZ — 90/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Kitten Cat Wet Food - 2.8 Oz, Natural, Stew, Grain Free — 89/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food - Chicken, Pea & Potato — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Source Chicken Senior — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Original Large Breed Senior — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Skin & Coat Recipe Adult Dog Food - Chicken, 10 OZ — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Dry Dog Food - Lamb & Oatmeal — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Source Beef and Bison Adult — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Source Natural Adult Wet Food - High Protein, Stew, Split Cups, 2.65 oz — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Original Senior Dry Dog Food - Lamb & Oatmeal — 89/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Lamb and Oatmeal — 88/100
• Simply Nourish Original Puppy Dry Dog Food - Lamb & Oatmeal — 88/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Dry Food - Chicken & Pea, Natural, Grain Free — 88/100
• Simply Nourish Homestyle Adult Wet Dog Food - 9 oz — 88/100
• Simply Nourish Source Puppy - High Protein, Chicken & Grain — 88/100
• Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe — 88/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Dry Dog Food - Chicken & Brown Rice — 88/100
• Simply Nourish Original Senior Dry Dog Food - Chicken & Brown Rice — 88/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Chicken and Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Dry Dog Food - Salmon & Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Fish and Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Puppy Chicken and Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Puppy Salmon and Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Senior Chicken and Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Small Breed Adult Lamb and Brown Rice — 87/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken & Rice Stew, 3 oz — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Gut Health Recipe Adult Dog Food - Chicken & Pumpkin, 10 OZ — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Senior Wet Dog Food - Chicken & Rice Stew, 10 oz — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Original Senior Wet Dog Food - Chicken & Vegetable, Grain Free, 10 oz — 87/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken & Rice Stew, 10 oz — 87/100
• Simply Nourish® Source Indoor Cat Dry Food - Salmon, Natural, High-Protein, Grain Free — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Wet Dog Food - Pate, Fish & Sweet Potato in Broth, 10 oz — 87/100
• Simply Nourish Source Adult - High Protein, Beef & Grain — 87/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Dry Food - Salmon & Peas, Natural, Grain Free — 87/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken & Vegetable Stew, 3 oz — 86/100
• Simply Nourish® Natural Solutions Skin & Coat All Life Stage Dog Meal Topper - 3 Oz., — 86/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Meal Topper - 1.4 Oz, Natural, Grain Free — 86/100
• Simply Nourish Natural Adult Wet Cat Food - Pate, Split Cups, 2.65 oz — 86/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Beef & Vegetable Stew, 3 oz — 86/100
• Simply Nourish® Limited Ingredient Diet Senior Dry Dog Food - Salmon & Sweet Potato — 86/100
• Simply Nourish® Fresh Market Adult Frozen Dog Food - Turkey & Sweet Potato — 85/100
• Simply Nourish Grain Free Large Breed Adult — 85/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Large Breed Adult Salmon and Sweet Potato — 85/100
• Simply Nourish Original Large Breed Adult Salmon and Sweet Potato — 85/100
• Simply Nourish® Fresh Market Adult Frozen Dog Food - Chicken & Vegetable — 85/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Adult Wet Dog Food - Chicken & Pasta Stew, 10 oz — 85/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Wet Dog Food - Shreds, Chicken & Pasta Stew, 3 oz — 85/100
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Wet Dog Food - Variety Pack, 12 ct — 85/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Wet Dog Food - Pate, Lamb & Sweet Potato in Broth, 10 oz — 84/100
• Simply Nourish Urinary Tract Health and Hairball Control Adult Cat Food - Natural, 3 OZ — 84/100
• Simply Nourish® Urinary Tract & Hairball Control Adult Dry Cat Food - Natural, Chicken — 84/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Adult Salmon and Sweet Potato — 84/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Dry Food - Chicken & Brown Rice, Natural, With-Grain — 82/100
• Simply Nourish Source Beef Adult — 82/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Lamb and Pea — 82/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Hairball Control Indoor Cat Dry Food - Salmon, Natural, With-Grain — 81/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Wet Dog Food - Pate, Duck & Sweet Potato in Broth, 10 oz — 81/100
• Simply Nourish Cat - Adult, Wet Food, Stew, Grain Free, Ocean Fish, 2.8 OZ — 81/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Wet Dog Food - Flaked, Tuna, Seabass & Rice Stew, 10 oz — 80/100
• Simply Nourish Original Large Breed Puppy Chicken and Brown Rice — 78/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Flaked, Tuna & Salmon Stew, 10 oz — 78/100
• Simply Nourish® Grain Free Wet Dog Food - Flaked, Tuna & Salmon Stew, 3 oz — 78/100
• Simply Nourish® Cat Wet Food - 36 Oz, Natural, Shreds in a Light Cream Sauce, With-Grain — 73/100
• Simply Nourish® Cat Wet Food - Variety Pack, Natural, Stew — 65/100
• Simply Nourish Source Fisherman's Finest Adult — 62/100
• Simply Nourish Source Hunter's Harvest Adult — 62/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Small Breed Adult Dry Dog Food - Chicken, Pea & Potato — 59/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Adult Beef and Lamb Stew — 57/100
• Simply Nourish Homestyle Adult Wet Dog Food - Variety Pack — 57/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Puppy Chicken and Rice Stew — 56/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Puppy Chicken and Rice Stew Tray — 56/100
• Simply Nourish Grain Free Adult — 56/100
• Simply Nourish Grain Free Small Breed Adult — 56/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Senior — 56/100
• Simply Nourish Adult Wet Cat Food - Natural, Mousse, 3 Oz — 54/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Adult Beef and Vegetable Stew Grain Free — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Adult Chicken and Rice Stew — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Hip & Joint Recipe — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Small Breed Adult Chicken and Rice Stew Tray — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Beef and Vegetable Stew — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Chicken and Beef Stew — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Chicken and Tuna Stew — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Chicken and Vegetable Stew — 53/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Small Breed Adult Chicken and Vegetable Stew Grain Free Tray — 52/100
• Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Tuna and Salmon Stew — 51/100
• Simply Nourish® Adult Wet Cat Food - Cuts in Gravy, Split Cup, 2.65oz — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Healthy Weight Adult — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Healthy Weight Large Breed Adult — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Healthy Weight Small Breed Adult — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Large Breed Adult Chicken and Brown Rice — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Small Breed Adult Chicken and Brown Rice — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Small Breed Puppy Chicken and Brown Rice — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Original Small Breed Senior Chicken and Brown Rice — 50/100
• Simply Nourish Shreds Adult Beef and Rice Stew — 49/100
• Simply Nourish® Original Cat Wet Food - Flaked, Stew, Grain Free, 2.8 Oz — 44/100
• Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Puppy Salmon and Sweet Potato — 40/100
• Simply Nourish Adult Dog Meal Topper - Shreds, 9 OZ — not scored
• Simply Nourish Homestyle Adult Wet Dog Food - Complete Meal or Meal Topper, 9 oz — not scored
• Simply Nourish Original Adult Dog Meal Topper - Shreds, Variety Pack, 12 ct — not scored
• Simply Nourish Puree Adult Dog Food Topper - Pumpkin, 3 oz — not scored

Frequently asked questions

Who makes Simply Nourish pet food?

Simply Nourish is manufactured by PetSmart house brand.

Where is Simply Nourish made?

Simply Nourish pet food is made in US.

Is Simply Nourish WSAVA-aligned?

Simply Nourish is not on our WSAVA-aligned shortlist. That doesn't automatically mean the food is poor quality — many strong brands haven't pursued WSAVA recognition — but it means we lack independent confirmation of feeding-trial validation and on-staff veterinary nutritionist staffing.

Has Simply Nourish ever been recalled?

No Simply Nourish products match any FDA recall in our tracked feed. Two caveats worth stating plainly: our feed covers FDA recall notices from late 2025 onward, so a recall older than that would not appear here; and brand matching is deliberately conservative, so a recall naming a parent company or a co-manufacturer rather than Simply Nourish itself may not be linked. For a definitive answer, check the FDA's own recall database.

How does Simply Nourish score in our analysis?

Simply Nourish averages 82/100 across 164 products in our catalog. Individual product scores combine ingredient quality, AAFCO compliance, and controversial-additive severity. See the methodology page for the full algorithm.

As an Amazon Associate, KibbleWatcher earns from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. Our scoring is independent of any affiliate revenue.