Old Mother Hubbard Dog Food Review

Average score: 60/100 across 26 dog food products.

Top Old Mother Hubbard products

1. Old Mother Hubbard Classic Minty Fresh Breath (Spearmint, Parsley & Fennel) — 87/100
2. Old Mother Hubbard® Original Small Biscuit Dog Treats - Natural, Variety Pack — 87/100
3. Old Mother Hubbard BITZ Assorted Mix (Chicken, Liver & Vegetables) — 86/100
4. Old Mother Hubbard Original Assortment Dog Biscuits — 86/100
5. Old Mother Hubbard Extra Tasty Assorted Dog Treats, Mini — 86/100

All Old Mother Hubbard products (26)

• Old Mother Hubbard® P-Nuttier Large Biscuit Dog Treats - Natural — 85/100
• Old Mother Hubbard® P-Nuttier Mini Biscuit Dog Treats - Natural — 85/100
• Old Mother Hubbard® P-Nuttier Small Biscuit Dog Treats - Natural — 85/100
• Old Mother Hubbard & Milkbar Collaboration All Life Stages Dog Treat - 10 oz — 84/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Hip & Joint (Chicken, Apples, Oats & Carrots) — 84/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Chicken Pot Pie (Chicken, Carrots & Peas) — 52/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Chick’N’Apples (Chicken & Apples) — 52/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Original Mix (Original, Chicken, Cheddar & CharTar) — 52/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Savory Mix (Bac’N’Cheez, Liv’R’Crunch & P-Nuttier) — 52/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Liv’R’Crunch (Liver, Eggs, Apples & Carrots0 — 51/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Puppy (Chicken & Oatmeal) — 51/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Bac’N’Cheez (Bacon & Cheese) — 50/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic P-Nuttier (Peanut Butter) — 50/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Seasonal P-Nuttier (Peanut Butter) — 50/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Limited Edition P’Nutty B-Day Party (Peanut Butter with Vanilla Yogurt Icing) — 50/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic All The Fixins (Turkey & Sweet Potatoes) — 37/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic P-Nuttier ‘N Nanners (Peanut Butter & Bananas) — 37/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Pick of the Patch (Pumpkins & Carrots) — 37/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Classic Just Vegg’N (Carrots, Sweet Potatoes & Apples) — 30/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Wholesome Indulgences Bacon, Oats & Maple — 30/100
• Old Mother Hubbard Wholesome Indulgences Peanut Butter & Banana — 30/100

Frequently asked questions

Is Old Mother Hubbard WSAVA-aligned?

Old Mother Hubbard is not on our WSAVA-aligned shortlist. That doesn't automatically mean the food is poor quality — many strong brands haven't pursued WSAVA recognition — but it means we lack independent confirmation of feeding-trial validation and on-staff veterinary nutritionist staffing.

Has Old Mother Hubbard ever been recalled?

No Old Mother Hubbard products match any FDA recall in our tracked feed. Two caveats worth stating plainly: our feed covers FDA recall notices from late 2025 onward, so a recall older than that would not appear here; and brand matching is deliberately conservative, so a recall naming a parent company or a co-manufacturer rather than Old Mother Hubbard itself may not be linked. For a definitive answer, check the FDA's own recall database.

How does Old Mother Hubbard score in our analysis?

Old Mother Hubbard averages 60/100 across 26 products in our catalog. Individual product scores combine ingredient quality, AAFCO compliance, and controversial-additive severity. See the methodology page for the full algorithm.

As an Amazon Associate, KibbleWatcher earns from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. Our scoring is independent of any affiliate revenue.